The Complete Guide to Food and Drinks at Disney Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point

Sharing is caring!

Just like on Castaway Cay, one of the best things about a day at Lighthouse Point is that you really don’t need to plan much around food — it’s included, it’s easy, and once you know your way around the island, it makes the whole day even better.

I get asked a lot how Lighthouse Point compares to Castaway Cay when it comes to eating on the island, so I wanted to put together a full breakdown of where to go, what to expect, and a few honest thoughts along the way.

Related: The Complete Guide to Food on Castaway Cay

Related: My Complete Guide to Lighthouse Point

A Quick Note on the Flies (Yes, I’m Addressing It)

If you did any research on Lighthouse Point when it first opened, you probably came across a lot of chatter about flies around the food.

I’m not going to pretend that wasn’t a real issue in the early days — it absolutely was, and it was one of the more talked-about parts of the island’s debut.

Here’s the good news: Disney took this seriously, and it’s simply not the problem it once was.

Between adjustments to food service areas and a bit of time for the island’s ecosystem to settle after all that construction, this has been largely resolved.

So don’t let old reviews scare you off — I want you to go in with realistic expectations, not outdated ones.

Related: Lighthouse Point vs Castaway Cay – Which Should You Choose?

Getting Your Bearings: The Two Sides of the Island

Lighthouse Point is laid out differently than Castaway Cay, so it’s worth understanding the geography before you go.

When you arrive at Mabrika Cove, you’re on the calmer side of the island.

This is where you’ll find your first food and drink stop of the day before you even reach the main beach areas.

And yes, there is that walk from the ship. It is 0.6 miles and takes around 12 to 15 minutes depending upon your walking speed.

There are golf carts available drive by Cast Members if you have accessibility needs – just go to Guest Services to book this on the way out.

There are also free strollers and wagons just outside the ship on the dock. They are first come first serve, but there are usually plenty available.

From there, a tram takes you over to the other side of the island which is where the bulk of the island’s dining and beach life happens.

This side splits into the Family Beach area to the south and Serenity Bay (the adults-only section) to the north, with the Goombay Cultural Center and the family water play area sitting in the middle.

Your First Stop: Mangroves & Go (Mabrika Cove)

Before you even get on the tram, there’s Mangroves & Go, where you can grab coffee, cold brew, frozen drinks, and even a Dole Whip to start your day.

It’s a nice, easy way to fuel up before heading over to the beach side of the island — and honestly, the menu here is more extensive than I expected for what’s essentially just a first stop.

Specialty Coffees & Refreshers

Junkanoo Latte – $5.75 – Illy Cold Brew, Vanilla, Lavender
Mangroves Café – $8 – 818 Blanco Tequila, Kahlua, Baileys, Espresso, Boba Pearl
Bahama Brew – $5.75 – Illy Cold Brew, Hawaiian Island, Coconut Cold Cream
Island Date – $5.75 – Pomegranate Green Tea, Date
Cay Breeze – $5.75 – Pineapple Smoothie, Coconut Water, Lemonade
Banana Bliss – $5.75 – Pandan, Banana, French Vanilla, Soda
Island Tonic – $8 – Fever Tree Indian Tonic, Illy Cold Brew, Amaro Montenegro, Fresh Orange

Barista’s Favorites (made with Bahamas Coffee Roasters)
Iced Coffee – Single $3.5 | Double $4.75
Espresso – Single $2.75 | Double $3.75
Cappuccino – Single $3.5 | Double $4.75
Cold Brew – Small $3.5 | Large $4
Latte – Single $3.5 | Double $4.75

Lighthouse Point Sierra Tumbler – $21 (includes a non-alcoholic signature coffee — a nice souvenir if you’re a coffee lover)

Dole Whips
Eleuthera Swirl – $6.5 – Mango Dole Whip®, Pineapple Dole Whip®, Mango Boba
Mango Dole Whip® – $6.5
Pineapple Dole Whip® – $6.5

Draft Beer
Pirates Republic Pineapple Pilsner – $7.25
Terrapin Luau Krunkles Passion Orange Guava IPA – $8

If you’re staying at one of the Mabrika Cove Cabanas, there’s a private dining spot exclusively for cabana guests.

Lunch: True-True BBQ, True-True Too BBQ, and Serenity Bay BBQ

Here’s the biggest difference from Castaway Cay that trips people up: on Lighthouse Point, all three lunch buffet locations serve the exact same menu.

Unlike Castaway Cay, where the Serenity Bay BBQ, the new Hangar 98, has slightly different food, here it really just comes down to which one is closest to where you’ve set up for the day.

True-True BBQ sits closest to the Family Beach and tram stop, and it’s set up with four separate serving stations rather than one long buffet line, which actually makes it feel a little less chaotic than you might expect.

True-True Too BBQ is just along from there, also on the family side.

Serenity Bay BBQ is the adults-only version, tucked up in the Serenity Bay area to the north.

True-True BBQ Menu

Flavorful Fish

• Freshly Grilled Bahamian-Style Lime and Ginger-Marinated Snapper
• Grilled Salmon with Pineapple Salsa

Sides: Pickled Vegetables, Yucca Fries, Grilled Corn and Broccoli, Coleslaw, Grilled Pineapple and Black Bean Salad, Tomato-Shallot Salad

Chicken and Seafood Rice Bowls

• Pan-Served Bahamian Pigeon Peas & Rice with Marinated Chicken
• Pan-Served Seafood Jambalaya

Sides: Oven-Baked Plantain, Fried Okra, Coleslaw, Tomato-Shallot Salad

BBQ Ribs and Rotisserie Chicken

• Carved Rotisserie Chicken and Slow-Cooked BBQ Ribs
• Plant-Based Island Curry with Tofu, Ginger, Cilantro and Potatoes

Sides: Baked Mac & Cheese, Grilled Corn on the Cob, American Coleslaw, Tomato-Shallot Salad, Grilled Pineapple-Black Bean Salad, French Fries

Beach BBQ Burgers
Fresh from the Grill: Cheeseburgers, Hot Dogs, Impossible Burgers™, and Crisp Spicy Chicken Sandwiches

Sides: Texas Potato Salad, Coleslaw, French Fries

The food here has a distinctly more Bahamian feel compared to Castaway Cay.

You’ll find the familiar comfort food — cheeseburgers, hot dogs, a plant-based burger option, and a spicy fried chicken sandwich — but the real standouts are the more island-inspired dishes: Bahamian pigeon peas and rice served with either chicken or seafood, a seafood-forward rice dish similar to a paella, and grilled Bahamian-style snapper with a lime and ginger marinade.

Sides lean into the same island flavors, with options like fried plantains, fried okra, yucca fries, and a pineapple black bean salad that I’d happily eat on its own as a full meal.

There’s also a proper vegetarian section at every BBQ location, with a plant-based island curry, rice and peas, and fried okra.

The Cabana Perk Worth Knowing About

Just like Hangar 98 back on Castaway Cay, cabana guests here get access to made-to-order steak, which isn’t available to the general buffet crowd.

This is only for Mabrika Cove Cabanas. The Serenity Bay cabanas do not have an exlusive location for food.

When I had a Cabana on Serenity Bay I sent to the Serenity Bay BBQ but brought the food back to the cabana to eat.

Related: Is a Serenity Bay Cabana Worth it on Disney’s Lighthouse Point?

Allergy-Friendly Dining

If you or someone in your group has dietary restrictions, there’s a dedicated allergy-friendly menu available at the BBQ locations.

Entrées

Grilled Salmon Filet
Pineapple, Cilantro and Chili Salsa, Pigeon Peas and Rice, Grilled Broccoli
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Shellfish, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Marinated Grilled Snapper
Bahamian-Style with Lime, Pigeon Peas and Rice, Grilled Broccoli
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Shellfish, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Disney Lookout Cay Spiced Rotisserie Chicken
Rubbed with Brown Sugar, Clove, Cayenne Pepper, Cinnamon, Thyme, and Ginger, Marinated for 24 Hours, with Grilled Pineapple and Black Bean Salad, French Fries
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Grilled BBQ Ribs
with “Smoky BBQ” Sauce, Grilled Broccoli, Corn on the Cob
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Grilled Hot Dog
with choice of Caraway, Riesling Wine Sauerkraut, or Beef Chili, served on an Allergy-Friendly Bun, Tomato-Cucumber Salad, French Fries
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Grilled Hamburger
Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Red Onion, Tomato, and Pickles, served on an Allergy-Friendly Bun, Coleslaw, French Fries
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Grilled Cheeseburger
Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Red Onion, Tomato, and Pickles, served on an Allergy-Friendly Bun, Coleslaw, French Fries
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Plant Based Island Curry
with Tofu, Ginger, Cilantro, Potatoes, Pigeon Peas and Rice, Oven-Baked Plantain Slices
For Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut, and Sesame Allergies

Dessert

Allergy-Friendly Cookies
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

Coconut Milk Frozen Dessert
For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies

As always, mention any allergies to your server onboard the night before, so the team on the island can prepare accordingly.

Drinks: Where to Find Them

Lighthouse Point has bars scattered across the Atlantic Ocean side, and much like the lunch spots, they’re essentially interchangeable — the same menu shows up at each one, so it really just comes down to which one you are closest to.

General Bar Menu (Bow & Ribbon, Watering Hole, Reef & Wreck)

Bubbles
Moët & Chandon ICE | Pommery Gold Pop | Pommery Pink Pop | Bottega Limoncino Spritz

Seltzers
Volley – Zesty Lime
White Claw – Black Cherry | Mango | Watermelon
Topo Chico – Strawberry Guava

Beer
Kalik | Sands

Coffees & Refreshers
Bahama Brew – Illy Cold Brew, Hawaiian Island, Coconut Cold Cream
Junkanoo Latte – Lavender, Vanilla, Illy Cold Brew
Cay Breeze – Pineapple, Coconut Water, Lemonade
Island Date – Pomegranate Green Tea, Date

Specials
Eleuthera Euphoria – Goslings Spirited Seas Ocean Aged Rum, Pineapple, Dole Whip Pineapple
Butterfly Switcha – Lemonade, Jasmine Green Tea, Electricdust Blue Buzz

Cocktails
Cherry Colada – SelvaRey White Rum, Coconut, Pineapple, Black Cherry
Junkanoo Juice – Zaya Cocobana Rum, Banana, Passion Orange Guava, Pineapple, Lime
Bahama Sling – Malibu Peach, Cointreau, Lime, Orgeat, Bitters

Zero Proof (Non-Alcoholic)
Aqua Tonic – Ace Brunswick Spades, Fever Tree Elderflower, Pineapple Chunks, Fresh Mint, Lime
Amalfi Spritz – Lyre’s Italian Spritz, Lyre’s Sparkling Classico

All sales are subject to Bahamian tax.

The Blue Hole Bar (Serenity Bay, Adults Only)

This is the one bar on the island space reserved exclusively for guests 18 and older, tucked up near Serenity Bay, and it has its own unique menu on top of the standard offerings above.

Frozen Drinks

Cascarilla Cooler – $8.5 – Cîroc Pineapple, Chinola, Mango, Orange, Apple, Lime, White Chocolate Foam
Tropical Fashion – $9 – Angel’s Envy Bourbon, Cherry Heering, Mixed Berries, Lavender

On the Rocks

Blue Water Breeze – $8.5 – Bottega Limoncino, Zignum Reposado, Blue Curaçao, Lime, ElectroDust
Eleuthera Euphoria – $9 – Goslings Spirited Seas Rum, Pineapple Smoothie, Dole Whip Pineapple
Shipwrecker – $8.5 – Teremana Reposado, Lime, Agave, Coconut, Ube Condensed Milk
Smash – $8.5 – Starr 7 Years Rum, Malibu, Apricot Brandy, Pineapple, Orange, Lime, Angostura
Island Colada – $9 – SelvaRey Coconut Rum, Pineapple, Coconut Water, Cream, Lime
Caribbean Punch – $8.5 – Ford’s Gin, Condensed Milk, Coconut Water

Zero Proof

Aqua Tonic – $9 – Ace Brunswick Spades, Fever Tree Elderflower, Pineapple Chunks, Fresh Mint, Lime
Amalfi Spritz – $9 – Lyre’s Italian Spritz, Lyre’s Sparkling Classico

Wine

White
Zonin Pinot Grigio – $7.75
Moscato Castello del Poggio – $9.25
Selbach Riesling Kabinett – $9.5
Hampton Water Rosé – $10.5
Invivo SJP Sauvignon Blanc – $17

Red
Kim Crawford Pinot Noir – $9.5
Murphy Goode Merlot – $10

Champagne & Sparkling
Bottega Limoncino Spritz – $6.75
Prosecco – $8.25
Moët & Chandon Ice Imperial – $17
Veuve Clicquot Rich Rosé – $17.25
Taittinger La Française – $18.25
Pommery Pink Pop – $27
Pommery Gold Pop – $33

Beers & Seltzers
Volley – $6.75 – Zesty Lime
Topo Chico – $6.75 – Strawberry Guava
White Claw – $6.75 – Black Cherry | Mango | Watermelon
Truly – $6.75 – Pineapple | Wild Berry
Kalik – $7.5
Sands – $7.5

All sales subject to Bahamian tax.

Sandsational Smoothies (Non-Alcoholic)

For something non-alcoholic, especially handy if you’re cooling down with kids in tow, Sandsational Smoothies sits near the family water play area with its own dedicated menu.

Frozen Drinks
Pineapple Pleaser – $6.50 – Dole Whip Pineapple, Marshmallow Cream, Graham Crackers
Salted Coconut – $6.50 – Coconut Cream, Pineapple Juice, Salted Caramel, Caramel
Mango Float – $6.50 – Dole Whip Mango, Coconut Milk, Pineapple Juice, Mango Pearls
Tropical Teaser – $6.50 – Vanilla Ice Cream, Mango, Pineapple, Tropical Pop Rocks

Specialty Drinks
Peaches & Cream Iced Tea – $6 – Sour Peach, Peach, Cold Foam, Peach Slice
Guava Strawberry Colada – $6 – Guava Strawberry Mojito, Strawberry, Coconut, Strawberry Bursting Pearls
Spicy Watermelon Limeade – $6 – Mixology Lime, Spicy Watermelon Limeade, Watermelon Rock Candy Stick

I’ll be upfront: the food here is a step up from Castaway Cay in terms of variety and creativity, particularly if you enjoy Bahamian flavors rather than classic American BBQ.

Where Lighthouse Point falls a little short is the lack of variety between locations — since every BBQ spot and every bar serves the same thing, there isn’t quite the same “let’s try a different spot today” fun you get hopping between Cookie’s, Cookie’s Too, and Hangar 98.

Is the Food at Lighthouse Point Worth It?

Yes, without hesitation. It’s included, it’s tasty, and the more Bahamian-inspired menu genuinely sets it apart from what you’re used to on Castaway Cay.

Go in expecting a relaxed beach lunch rather than a five-star meal, and you’ll have a wonderful day.

For more on planning your day at each of Disney’s private islands, check out my Complete Guide to Lighthouse Point and my Complete Guide to Food on Castaway Cay so you know exactly what to expect no matter which island your itinerary takes you to.