Disney Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point: 15 Things I Wish I Knew Before My First Visit

Sharing is caring!

I’ve visited Disney Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point many times now, and I have definitely changed the way I spend my day there.

There are things I really love about Lighthouse Point. The beach is absolutely beautiful, the water is an almost unbelievable shade of blue, and some of the food is better than you might expect from a cruise line beach buffet.

But there are also things I wish I had known before that first visit.

Lighthouse Point is very different from Castaway Cay. And I think one of the reasons some Disney Cruise guests are disappointed by it is that they arrive expecting Castaway Cay 2.0.

It really isn’t.

So if Lighthouse Point is on your Disney Cruise itinerary, here are the things I think you should know before you step off the ship.

1. Yes, That Walk Really Is Long. But …

We have to start with the pier.

You will hear a lot about the walk from the Disney ship at Lighthouse Point, and some of the reports make it sound like you are setting out on a major expedition.

You aren’t.

But it is still something you need to plan for.

The pier is around 0.6 miles long and completely exposed to the sun. It usually takes me around 12 to 15 minutes to walk it — although admittedly I am usually stopping to take photos and video of the ship.

The walk back always seems longer.

My biggest issue isn’t really the distance. It is the lack of shade.

If it is a hot day, you really feel it.

Wear a hat, sun screen and take a solar umbrella. I have had this one for a couple of years now and always take is with me on cruises and to the theme parks.

If you have young children, Disney provides complimentary wagons and strollers near the ship. Guests with accessibility needs can also ask about golf cart assistance.

And take water with you.

2. Getting to the Beach Takes Longer Than You Think

Reaching the end of the pier doesn’t mean you’ve reached the beach.

Once you arrive at Mabrika Cove, you go through the arrival area and then take a tram over to the main part of Lookout Cay.

The tram ride itself takes around 10 minutes.

This means getting from your stateroom to your beach chair can take quite a while.

It also means I wouldn’t plan on popping back to the ship for something you forgot.

I did this kind of thing on Castaway Cay without thinking too much about it. At Lighthouse Point, the walk and tram make returning to the ship much more of a commitment.

Pack what you need for the day and plan to stay.

3. Pick Up Your Towels When You Get Off the Tram

This is one I learned the annoying way.

Get your towels when you arrive.

On my first visit I walked all the way towards Serenity Bay without picking them up and then had to go searching for towels.

Not exactly a vacation disaster, but definitely something I don’t need to repeat.

4. The Beach Is the Best Thing About Lighthouse Point

There are things about Lighthouse Point that I think Disney could have done much better.

The beach isn’t one of them.

It is stunning.

In fact, purely in terms of sand and the color of the ocean, I think Lighthouse Point beats Castaway Cay.

The sand is beautifully soft and that turquoise-blue water can look almost unreal.

If your perfect port day involves finding a lounger, reading a book, swimming and doing very little else, you really don’t need to overcomplicate Lighthouse Point.

Sometimes the best plan is no plan.

5. But the Ocean Is Very Different From Castaway Cay

This is important, particularly if you are sailing with children.

Castaway Cay has protected water around the main family beach. Lighthouse Point faces the open ocean.

That means you can have waves and considerably more movement in the water.

Conditions obviously vary from day to day, but don’t assume you are going to find the same calm swimming experience you may have experienced at Castaway Cay.

I actually prefer the look of the beach at Lighthouse Point.

For swimming, I prefer Castaway Cay.

6. Don’t Automatically Book an Excursion

This is one of the biggest mistakes I think first-time visitors can make.

There are excursions available at Lighthouse Point, including snorkeling, biking, kayaking and tours that take you farther into Eleuthera.

But you absolutely do not need to book one.

The beach is the star here.

If this is your first visit, I would think carefully before filling several hours of your day with an excursion unless there is something you particularly want to experience.

You have already paid for access to one of the most beautiful beaches in the Bahamas.

Sometimes I would rather enjoy it.

Related: Lighthouse Point Activities

7. Lighthouse Point Has More Bahamian Food Than You Might Expect

I think the food is one of the better surprises at Lighthouse Point.

Yes, you can get the Disney Cruise beach-day staples such as burgers, hot dogs, chicken and ribs.

But there are also more interesting choices including Bahamian-style snapper, pigeon peas and rice, plantains, seafood dishes, yucca fries and island-inspired sides.

There are three main lunch locations:

True-True BBQ

True-True Too BBQ

Serenity Bay BBQ

The important thing to know is that you don’t need to walk across the island looking for a different menu.

The main BBQ locations serve essentially the same food.

So choose whichever makes the most sense for where you are spending your day.

8. I Wouldn’t Rush to Serenity Bay BBQ

If I’m spending the day in the adult area, Serenity Bay BBQ is obviously convenient.

But I don’t necessarily think it is the best place to eat.

I’ve found this area can feel crowded, and on some visits the live entertainment has been so loud that it really hasn’t felt particularly relaxing.

True-True and True-True Too aren’t that far away.

So being in Serenity Bay doesn’t mean you have to eat there.

9. The Early Fly Reports Shouldn’t Put You Off

If you researched Lighthouse Point when it first opened, you probably saw the reports about flies around the food.

I’ve visited numerous times and this simply hasn’t been an issue for me.

Whatever Disney did to improve the situation seems to have worked.

I wouldn’t let those early reports influence how you plan your day now.

10. Serenity Bay Isn’t What You Expect

This was probably my biggest surprise.

I love Serenity Bay on Castaway Cay.

It feels like you’ve escaped somewhere completely separate from the family beach.

At Lighthouse Point?

Not so much.

The adults-only area is essentially a continuation of the same beach. There isn’t a separate, secluded destination in the way there is on Castaway Cay.

There are markers separating the adult and family sections, but that’s about it.

The beach itself is gorgeous.

But if you’re imagining the Castaway Cay Serenity Bay experience, adjust your expectations.

11. You Probably Don’t Need a Cabana

I finally managed to book a Serenity Bay cabana on one of my visits.

And I loved being able to experience it.

The service was excellent, we had comfortable shaded seating, loungers, towels, a stocked refrigerator, snacks and easy access to the beach.

Would I pay for one again for two adults?

No.

The problem is that Lighthouse Point already gives you the thing I wanted most from the cabana: access to a beautiful beach with loungers and umbrellas.

We simply didn’t need all that extra space.

For a larger group, particularly if you are splitting the cost between several people, the calculation could be very different.

But don’t feel as though missing out on a cabana reservation means you’ve missed the best Lighthouse Point experience.

You haven’t.

12. Don’t Expect Castaway Cay Levels of Disney Theming

This is where I think expectations really matter.

Castaway Cay feels unmistakably Disney.

Lighthouse Point feels much more like a beautiful Bahamian beach destination that happens to be operated by Disney.

That isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

Disney made a point of incorporating Bahamian design and culture into Lookout Cay, and there are some lovely details.

But personally, I don’t think the cultural elements have lived up to what was promised before Lighthouse Point opened.

I wanted the Goombay Cultural Center and the cultural experiences to be a much bigger part of the destination.

They aren’t.

Perhaps this will evolve as Lighthouse Point matures, but right now there are areas that still feel a little unfinished to me.

13. Do Make Time for the Characters

One thing Disney does very well here is the characters.

Mickey, Minnie and friends have colorful outfits created specifically for Lookout Cay, with designs inspired by Bahamian culture.

If you enjoy character photos, these are some you won’t get on the ship.

Check the Disney Cruise Line Navigator app for appearance times rather than hoping you happen to walk past at the right moment.

14. Don’t Spend the Whole Day Chasing Activities

There is plenty to do.

Kids have Rush Out Gush Out, Sebastian’s Cove offers supervised activities, there are character appearances and cultural experiences, and you can explore the nature trail or book a Port Adventure.

But I don’t think Lighthouse Point needs to be treated like a theme park.

You don’t need an itinerary that accounts for every 20 minutes.

For me, this destination works much better when I slow down.

Beach.

Lunch.

Swim.

Maybe a drink.

Explore a little.

Back to the beach.

That’s a pretty good Disney Cruise port day.

15. Lighthouse Point Gets Better Once You Stop Comparing It With Castaway Cay

This is probably the biggest thing I wish I’d understood on my first visit.

I still prefer Castaway Cay overall.

Castaway Cay is easier to navigate, the water is more protected, Serenity Bay feels like a true adults-only escape, and the whole destination feels more polished and unmistakably Disney.

But Lighthouse Point has something Castaway Cay doesn’t.

That beach.

The soft sand, open ocean and extraordinary blue water make it feel much more like a natural Bahamian beach.

And once I stopped expecting Lighthouse Point to be another Castaway Cay, I started appreciating it much more for what it actually is.

How I Would Spend a Perfect Day at Lighthouse Point

If I were visiting tomorrow, I wouldn’t book an excursion.

I’d get off the ship reasonably early, but I wouldn’t feel the need to join the first rush of guests leaving.

I’d bring water for the pier walk, pick up my towel as soon as I got off the tram and head towards the beach.

If I were traveling without children, I’d probably start at Serenity Bay but walk farther along to find a quieter spot.

Then I would do very little for a couple of hours.

Swim. Read. Take far too many photos of the water.

For lunch, I’d head to whichever BBQ location looked least busy and choose some of the more Bahamian dishes rather than automatically getting a burger.

I’d check the Navigator app to see if there were any character appearances or activities I wanted to catch, perhaps walk the nature trail, and then go straight back to the beach.

And I wouldn’t leave it until the last possible minute to head back.

Because remember that pier?

You have to walk it again.

Is Lighthouse Point Worth Getting Off the Ship For?

Absolutely.

I’ve heard people say that they don’t like Lighthouse Point and would rather stay onboard.

I wouldn’t.

It isn’t perfect. There are things I think Disney could have designed better, and there are certainly things I prefer about Castaway Cay.

But Lighthouse Point has one of the most beautiful beaches you can experience on a Disney Cruise.

My advice?

Don’t arrive expecting Castaway Cay.

Don’t overschedule your day.

And don’t forget your sunglasses, sunscreen and water bottle.

Then find a lounger, look at that ridiculously blue ocean and enjoy where you actually are.

Because Lighthouse Point may not be Castaway Cay.

But it doesn’t need to be.